Posts Tagged ‘Kashmir’

Pahalgam: April 2024

We were right there!
20 of us, from Mumbai. One big group.
Just about one year back.
April 7-15, 2024. To be precise.
Travelling all those beautiful places.
Srinagar, Gulmarg, Sonmarg and…
Pahalgam! Yes, the same Pahalgam!
The same lush green large meadows where we had a wonderful time enjoying the beauty of Kashmir, taking so many fun pictures, drinking kahwa…

Coming back from that trip, I was feeling so good about Kashmir.

Having engaged at length with the drivers who were with us right through, spoken to the many other locals we got to meet, we could sense a certain return of positivity. About the return to normalisation of the region. The return of the tourists, the shops and hotels and restaurants doing good business again, the Dal Lake looking busy with shikaras all over again!

While the old wounds still showed up a little, the feeling was that if this tourism sustained and grew, if there was also some other industries opening up there, if the jobs returned back and along with it, a certain prosperity to the youth of the state, then slowly but surely, the thoughts and brainwashing around separatism will die down, and in a few years or maybe in a decade or two, Kashmir will become fully normalised like any other state in India.

The journey had started. The hope was alive.

And then this!!

Besides the sheer gruesome nature of the tragedy that it is, it puts back just so many years of hard and painstaking efforts to have got to this point!

If an enemy had a vision that with one attack, we put back the efforts of last 10 years and make it much harder for the region to fully integrate into India, they could have not thought of a better way to make that happen!

In the absolute calm and normalcy of a Kashmir vacation, in the middle of Pahalgam, a must-visit spot in a Kashmir vacation, if tourists get hit in this manner, it is enough to scare away anyone from travelling there! Which honeymooning couple wants to dare to go there now? Which group of 50-somethings want to make this place their annual vacation spot?

Heck, as I look back a year now, and remember the absolutely wonderful holiday we had there, I have one more footnote that comes to mind.. that we were lucky to have returned back safely!

Damn! We were on vacation. Not on some adventure trip. We shouldn’t be thinking that we were lucky to return back safely!

One incident.
To cripple an entire journey to normalcy.

Then again, that delicate vulnerability of the region was always there. Perhaps.

We only wished that nothing of the kind happens and many years go by, and there is full-fledged normalcy. But with the enemy being so close, with very thick forests and mountains that make it impossible to completely secure, and with so many traitors embedded inside already, the risks were always there.

Damn! Double damn!!

Yes, there should be action. To show unequivocally that we are not suckers, we will fight back, we will protect ourselves, our people, our land.

But the worst is already done, for Kashmir! It goes back to that “insecure” zone that keeps mainstream tourists away, that will now not see the return of industry and other jobs anytime soon.

Unfortunately.

Slice of history films like Khelein Hum Jee Jaan Sey provoke thoughts beyond the film itself.

The way we read the history and as shown in the film, these freedom fighters appear to be gallant and brave, and fighting for a just cause. And yet, at the time, they rebelled. Went against the system. Were violent. Hurt and even killed people.

History written from a different point of view could easily have painted them as gruesome villains of the peace.

Which brings me to the point of what really motivates the so-called freedom fighter?

Be it the school teacher and students in Bengal or the ultras in Kashmir or Assam or the Maoists?! What makes them go headway, at times killing people, causing a lot of damage, and fighting what’s usually a futile cause (from a winning point of view), and yet they carry on. With passion, dedication and commitment. WHY??

Is it the same reason why soldiers go to the battlefield, knowing fully well that they may not return back at all?

I don’t have serious answers to this.. only questions. And I am keen to know the answers! Will tomorrow’s kids see Kashmiri ultras as freedom fighters, will they serenade the Maoists as the heroes who fought with their lives to get their own country? There is always a point of view, and looking at one side only tells half the story. Only a few crazy folks can walk into a spray of bullets for no reason. The rest who do, do believe that they are sacrificing their lives for a bigger cause, and it is worth it.

Without bias on what side they are fighting for, I do appreciate the level of motivation that gets a person to walk into a sure death, because he believes that his cause and his land requires that sacrifice. Few can do this.. !